John Deere 5050 D vs Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3: Detailed Tractor Comparison

Choosing the right tractor is crucial for enhancing your farm productivity and also reducing operational challenges. Two popular options in the Indian market are the John Deere 5050 D and the Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3, known for their power, efficiency, and versatility. Both models are designed to handle various farming tasks, from plowing to hauling, but they cater to different needs based on their features and performance. This detailed comparison will help you understand the key differences between these tractors in terms of their engine power, transmission, hydraulics, brakes, and pricing. Whether you’re looking for superior lifting capacity or fuel efficiency, this guide will provide you with the insights needed to choose the best tractor for your agricultural needs.

Also Read: Kubota MU5501 vs Mahindra Arjun Novo 605 DI-i-with AC Cabin: A Detailed Comparison for Farmers

Key Differences Between John Deere 5050 D and Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3

1. Engine Performance

The engine is the most important part for any tractor, as it determines the performance and reliability. Both the John Deere 5050 D and the Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3 come with powerful 3-cylinder diesel engines, ensuring strong performance in the field.

The John Deere 5050 D delivers a slight edge in power with 50 HP compared to the 49 HP of the Eicher model. Its engine runs at 2100 RPM and uses a coolant-cooled system, which improves efficiency and durability during long hours of work. This makes it a great choice for demanding tasks like plowing and heavy hauling. The dry-type dual-element air filter adds further protection to its engine.

On the other hand, the Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3 features a water-cooled engine. While it lacks a specific rated RPM and PTO power in its specifications, it is still reliable for standard farming operations, delivering consistent performance for daily agricultural activities.

In conclusion, the John Deere 5050 D excels in horsepower and cooling, while the Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3 is dependable for regular tasks.

2. Transmission

Smooth gear shifting plays a significant role in the efficiency and comfort of tractor operation.

The John Deere 5050 D features a Collarshift transmission with up to 4 reverse gears, providing smoother transitions for various tasks. On the other hand, the Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3 comes with a Side Shift Partial Constant Mesh transmission that ensures synchronized and effortless gear shifting under load.

3. Hydraulics and Lifting Capacity

Hydraulic systems are vital for handling implements and performing various farming tasks.

The Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3 has a superior lifting capacity of 2100 kg, making it more suitable for heavy-duty implements and large-scale operations. The John Deere 5050 D, with a lifting capacity of 1600 kg, is well-suited for medium-duty tasks.

4. Brakes and Steering

Safety and handling are crucial when operating tractors.

Both tractors come equipped with oil-immersed brakes for reliable performance. The Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3 offers slightly more robust multi-disc brakes, ensuring enhanced durability and control.

5. Dimensions and Weight

The size and weight of a tractor play a significant role in its overall stability and ease of operation. Heavier tractors are generally more stable, while lighter ones offer better maneuverability in tight spaces.

The John Deere 5050 D weighs 1870 kg, making it lighter and easier to handle in smaller fields or confined spaces. It has a wheelbase of 1970 mm, offering balanced support for its weight, and a ground clearance of 430 mm, which helps navigate uneven surfaces without damaging the undercarriage. Additionally, its turning radius of 2900 mm allows for smoother turns, especially in compact areas.

On the other hand, the Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3 weighs 2294 kg, providing greater stability and traction. This makes it an excellent choice for rough terrains and heavy-duty tasks, where a stable and sturdy tractor is essential.

The John Deere 5050 D is ideal for tasks requiring quick turns and better maneuverability, while the Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3 stands out for its stability on challenging terrain.

6. Pricing

Pricing is a significant factor in choosing a tractor.

Both models fall within a similar price range, with only slight variations. The John Deere 5050 D starts at a slightly lower price, making it more accessible for budget-conscious buyers.

7. Fuel Tank Capacity

Fuel efficiency and tank size determine how long a tractor can work without refueling.

The John Deere 5050 D has a marginally larger fuel tank, allowing for longer operational hours compared to the Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3.

Additional Features

While the John Deere 5050 D offers practical accessories like a canopy and wagon hitch, the Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3 provides additional tools and conveniences, such as a mobile charger and water bottle holder.

Also Read: Farmtrac 45 Powermaxx vs. Mahindra 575 DI: Comprehensive Analysis of Performance, Features, and Value for Farmers

CMV360 Says

Both the John Deere 5050 D and the Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3 are exceptional tractors with distinct strengths. The John Deere 5050 D is more affordable, lightweight, and versatile, while the Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3 offers superior lifting capacity, better stability, and advanced hydraulic features.

Your choice depends on your specific farming needs and budget. If you require a tractor for medium-scale tasks with a focus on cost-effectiveness, the John Deere 5050 D is an excellent option. However, if you need a powerful machine for heavy-duty tasks and enhanced convenience, the Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3 is worth considering.

FAQs

1. Which tractor has better lifting capacity?
The Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3 has a higher lifting capacity of 2100 kg compared to the John Deere 5050 D, which can lift up to 1600 kg.

2. What is the horsepower of these tractors?
The John Deere 5050 D delivers 50 HP, slightly higher than the Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3 at 49 HP.

3. Which tractor is heavier?
The Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3 is heavier, weighing 2294 kg compared to the John Deere 5050 D at 1870 kg.

4. Which model is better for tough terrains?
The Eicher 551 4WD Prima G3, with its heavier build and robust brakes, is better suited for tough terrains and demanding tasks.